Tales of Heroism and Tragedy Swirl Around Fire
By Kim Estep, Green Bay Press-Gazette
Reprinted with Permission from the Press-Gazette
On October 8, 1871, the most devastating forest fire in American history swept through
Northeast Wisconsin, claiming 1200 lives.
The anniversary of the Peshtigo Fire usually receives little note outside the region because
another horrific fire the same night -- the great Chicago Fire -- still seems to hog the headlines.
"Part of it is that myth of the cow -- Mrs. O'Leary's cow tipping over the lantern," said Debra
Anderson, an archivist for the University of Wisconsin-Green Bay Area Research Center,
referring to the way the Chicago fire allegedly started. "And, Chicago was and still is a bigger
While Chicago's story may be more colorful, researchers still find the Peshtigo Fire worth
studying, Anderson said.
The Area Research Center, the state historical society's depository for records for 11 counties in
Northeast Wisconsin, has papers and manuscripts of all kinds, she said.
The story of the Peshtigo Fire, gleaned from survivor accounts and conjecture, is that railroad
workers clearing land for tracks that Sunday evening started a brush fire which, somehow,
became an inferno.
It had been an unusually dry summer, and the fire moved fast. Some survivors said it moved so
fast it was "like a tornado."
The sudden, convulsive speed of the flames consumed available oxygen. Some trying to flee
burst into flames.
It scorched 1.2 million acres, although it skipped over Green Bay to burn parts of Door and
Kewaunee counties. The damage estimate was at $169 million, about the same as for the
The fire also burned 16 other towns, but the damage in Peshtigo was the worst. The city was
gone in an hour. In Peshtigo alone, 800 lives were lost.
"What most researchers find so fascinating is the effect it (the Peshtigo Fire) had on people's
lives. It was so horrific," Anderson said. "Some people thought it was the end of the world."
The fire produced countless stories of heroics and tragedy, which are collected at the research
center, as well as the Peshtigo Fire Museum in downtown Peshtigo.
There's the story of a man carrying a woman to safety he thought was his wife. When he found
out it wasn't her, he went crazy. People said the Peshtigo River was the only haven from the fire,
and one 13 year-old German immigrant girl said she held onto the horn of a cow all night in the
river to survive.
Anderson said the Peshtigo Fire receives just a small mention -- if any -- in history books. But
Stella Van Bogart, curator of the Peshtigo Fire Museum, maintains that the Peshtigo Fire still
generates plenty of attention. "Every year, we get a lot of mail, asking about it," she said. "The
whole city was gone within one hour. It still keeps people wondering."
The Peshtigo Fire Museum, located in a former church building, is located at the corner of Oconto Street and Ellis Avenue in Peshtigo. Hours are 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. daily, beginning Memorial Day weekend. Admission is free.